Hello dear
Welcome To Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub
At Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub, located in Fishers, Indiana, the essence of community and exceptional cuisine comes alive. Owners Courtney and Dave foster a warm, inviting atmosphere, where diners feel like family. The menu is a delightful exploration of classic Italian dishes, featuring remarkable pizzas, pastas, and appetizers, with standout options like the Mexican pizza and buttery pretzels served with zesty beer cheese. Patrons rave about the attentive staff and the vibrant vibe, especially during local events like the Indy 500. With half-price wine nights and a mug club for beer enthusiasts, Pearl Street Pizzeria promises a fulfilling dining experience for everyone.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
About
Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub
Welcome to Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub, a vibrant gem nestled in the heart of Fishers, Indiana. Located at 10462 Olio Rd, this establishment is not just another pizzeria; it's a hub of comfort food and community spirit. With a friendly and attentive staff that makes you feel like family, it’s no surprise that Pearl Street has garnered rave reviews from customers seeking a warm dining experience.
This lively pizzeria boasts a menu that features a delightful fusion of traditional Italian favorites and unique creations. Locals rave about the incredible range of options, from their fantastic pasta dishes to a selection of mouthwatering pizzas. Customers like John Englert have praised the Mexican pizza as the best they've ever had, showcasing the restaurant's flair for combining flavors that keep patrons coming back for more.
- Exceptional Drinks: Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub features a full bar with a wide array of cold draft beers and an appealing wine selection. For those looking for great deals, make sure to visit on a Tuesday for half-price bottles!
- Warm Atmosphere: The ambiance is perfect for casual dining or catching a game, with multiple TVs showcasing everything from local teams to major sporting events.
- Attentive Service: The staff, like Bailey, Mike, Courtney, and Dave, are frequently highlighted in reviews for their warm approach and personalized service, often remembering guests' drink preferences—an extraordinary touch that elevates the meal experience.
Beginning with their famous pretzel appetizer, which is chewy and accompanied by a delectable beer cheese dip, to exemplary pizzas like the supreme and mad Greek varieties, the menu at Pearl Street delights with exceptional flavor and quality in every bite. Customers have noted the appealing crust, which strikes a balance between thick and chewy without overwhelming oiliness—a testament to their craftsmanship.
Visitors like Matt T have enjoyed the spacious accommodations at the pizzeria, perfect for gatherings or casual dining moments alike. Whether you’re there for a simple dinner or a lively gathering, Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub delivers an unforgettable dining experience that is as much about the food as it is about the connections made over shared plates and laughter. Perfect for all occasions, it’s easy to see why guests feel like part of the family at this beloved establishment.
In conclusion, Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub is more than just a place to grab a bite: it’s a celebration of community, culture, and exceptional cuisine. If you’re looking for a dining experience that excellently combines comfort food with warmth and friendliness, look no further than Pearl Street—where every visit feels like coming home.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Everyone is very nice and friendly. Bailey and Mike even remember our drinks, lol. They are extra special! We haven't tried everything on the menu but every pasta, pizza, and appetizer has been fantastic. Best Mexican pizza I've ever had. Full bar and lots of cold draft beer. Wine too of course. Half price bottles on Tuesdays! Mug club gets you extra 4 onces of beer. You cannot go wrong if you like Italian. This place could be 6 stars. ”
“ Came for an early dinner, parking was easy to find. We were sat at a booth immediately. The waitress was very attentive and patient with us being first time guests. We started with the pretzel appetizer. They were soft and buttery with a side of beer cheese that had a slight spice to it. Also, we ordered a supreme and mad greek pizza. Both had excellent flavor and crust. We will definitely be back. ”
“ We attended a pine to posh here and the accommodations were great. The back area was reserved and we had a large open space to work and eat. The wings were amazing and the pizza was great. ”
“ I came in from Texas to attend the Indy 500. I visited Pearl Street three times in my four day trip. The vibe is phenomenal. The bar itself is lovely with lots of tvs to watch the Pacers magical playoff fun. The staff is fantastic and attentive, serving good pizza and great drinks. Courtney and Dave are the owners and made me feel like I was part of their family. ”
“ This pizza was unique! Deep dish but not overly oily. Was thick but so chewy. We mainly eat veggies and they had a couple veggie options. Would definitely come back. ”
“ Friendly Service, Quality Food & Variety! This is a welcome restaurant & bar to the area! We didn't know they were in Geist area because they are behind other buildings. Glad we discovered a Gem! ”
“ Dang, was pretty good, nice layout of reastraunt, we got togo and we didn't want to leave such a cool place for the family. A good mix of pup mixed drinks and family friendly with a touch of rustic coolness, allready made plans to watch a game next week at the pearl. ”
“ Great pizza and a large craft beer selection. Great atmosphere with a large bar and a patio for outdoor seating as well as a family dining area. ”